In that case, this seems like a learning opportunity for you.
Western European countries have rule of law and don’t disappear or mulch people when they break the law, letting them retain their rights.
This counterexample would seem to completely undermine your claim that America’s incredibly high incarceration rates are just “what happens” when citizens retain rights after breaking the law.
From the description it sounds like they have a point. If people reuse their passwords and then get hacked, the hackers are going to have access to their full accounts, including any information shared with them.
How is this different than if hackers reused passwords and hacked into Facebook accounts and then saw the user’s friends’ profiles?